User blog comment:Lord Loss/Monster Hunter Theory... Blog/@comment-95.93.30.63-20121117124740/@comment-4212769-20121117142840

1. The cave is too small. There is no sign of a cave-in.

2. People wouldn't build a village on a riverbed that is constantly under water (even in MHP3rd there is water, but I still wonder how the river bed is suddenly that high...)

3. People wouldn't build a village in an area regularly flooded.

4. Area 8 of the Flooded Forest is the nest of Royal Ludroth and other monsters (Gobul, Lagiacrus).